best index fund for wealth building

VTI vs VTSAX vs FZROX: Best Index Fund?

When I started investing, I spent three weeks trying to pick between VTI and VTSAX. I read forum posts. I made spreadsheets. Then I realized something. I was spending more time choosing a fund than I would spend managing it for the next 30 years. That is backwards.

If you are trying to find the best index fund for wealth building, the good news is that all three of these funds are excellent. VTI, VTSAX, and FZROX all give you broad exposure to the U.S. stock market at a very low cost. The differences between them are small. But they do exist. And those small differences matter more than you might think over decades.

This article compares them on what actually matters: fees, taxes, minimums, where you can buy them, and what they cost over 30 years. I will also share the simple two-fund portfolio I use. By the end, you will know which one fits your situation.

Expense Ratios and Fees Compared

Expense ratios are the annual fee a fund charges to manage your money. They sound tiny. They are not. A 0.03% fee on $100,000 is $30 per year. That sounds like nothing. But over 30 years, fees compound against you. Every dollar paid in fees is a dollar that never grows.

Fund Type Expense Ratio Minimum
VTI (Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF) ETF 0.03% Price of one share
VTSAX (Vanguard Total Stock Market Admiral) Mutual fund 0.04% $3,000
FZROX (Fidelity ZERO Total Market) Mutual fund 0.00% $0

On the surface, FZROX wins. Zero is zero. You cannot beat that. But there is a catch. FZROX tracks a proprietary Fidelity index, not the standard CRSP US Total Market Index that VTI and VTSAX follow. The performance is nearly identical in practice, but it is not the exact same benchmark.

VTI and VTSAX are legally share classes of the same Vanguard fund. They hold the exact same portfolio and have the same manager. The only difference is how you buy them. VTI trades like a stock. VTSAX is a traditional mutual fund.

For a $100,000 investment, the annual cost difference between VTI at 0.03% and VTSAX at 0.04% is $10 per year. That is one coffee. The difference between VTI and FZROX is $30 per year. Over 30 years, that adds up. But it is not a life-changing amount. Do not let this choice paralyze you.

Tax Efficiency: ETF vs Mutual Fund

If you are investing in a taxable brokerage account, tax efficiency matters. It can matter more than the expense ratio difference.

ETFs like VTI have a structural tax advantage over mutual funds. When investors sell shares of an ETF, the fund does not have to sell underlying stocks to raise cash. It uses a process called in-kind creation and redemption. That means VTI distributes fewer capital gains to shareholders. You pay less in taxes each year.

Mutual funds like VTSAX work differently. When investors sell, the fund may have to sell stocks. If those stocks have gains, the fund distributes those gains to all shareholders. You pay taxes on them, even if you did not sell anything yourself.

In practice, VTI and VTSAX have been unusually close on tax efficiency because they are share classes of the same fund. Vanguard's structure has historically reduced capital gains distributions for both. But the ETF wrapper still carries a structural edge. If you are investing in a taxable account, VTI is the slightly better choice.

FZROX is a mutual fund. It does not have the same structural tax advantage as an ETF. But its zero expense ratio can offset some of that. If you are investing in a tax-advantaged account like an IRA, the tax difference does not matter at all.

If you are wondering where to put your money first, see the 7-step financial planning framework. Taxable investing comes after you have filled your retirement accounts.

Where to Buy Each Fund

This is where the choice often makes itself.

You can buy VTI at almost any major brokerage. Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard all offer it commission-free. It trades like a stock, so you can buy one share or 100 shares, whenever the market is open.

VTSAX is only available through Vanguard. If you have an account at Fidelity or Schwab, buying VTSAX may cost you a transaction fee. Schwab, for example, has charged around $75 to buy Vanguard mutual funds. That fee wipes out any advantage. If you are not at Vanguard, VTSAX is not the right choice.

FZROX is only available at Fidelity. You cannot buy it at Vanguard or Schwab. If you already have a Fidelity account, FZROX is a great option. If you do not, you would need to open one. That is not a big deal, but it is a step.

Here is the simple version. If you are at Vanguard, buy VTI. If you are at Fidelity, buy FZROX. If you are at Schwab or anywhere else, buy VTI. If you want a broader list of what to hold alongside these funds, see the best investments to become a millionaire.

30-Year Cost Projection

Let me show you what these fees actually cost over time. I will use a $50,000 initial investment and a 10% gross annual return. That is higher than the historical average, but it makes the math easier. The point is the difference between fees, not the exact return.

Fund / Fee Level Expense Ratio 30-Year Fee Drag
FZROX 0.00% $0
VTI 0.03% ~$7,110
VTSAX 0.04% Slightly more than VTI
Average active fund 1.00% ~$86,000

Seven thousand dollars over 30 years. That is real money. But compare it to the average active fund, which charges 1.00%. On the same $50,000 investment, the active fund would cost you over $86,000 in fees. The difference between VTI and an average active fund is more than $79,000. The difference between VTI and FZROX is $7,000.

Both numbers matter. But if you are choosing between these three funds, you are already making a good decision. Do not let the $7,000 difference keep you out of the market for another six months. The cost of waiting is almost always higher than the fee difference.

If you want to understand how wealthier investors diversify beyond index funds, see how portfolios change after the first million. Public index funds are the base layer, not the whole picture.

The Simple 2-Fund Portfolio

You do not need 10 funds. You do not need to slice the market into small pieces. A two-fund portfolio is enough for most people. Here is what I use.

Fund 1: U.S. Total Market

This is VTI, VTSAX, or FZROX. It gives you exposure to the entire U.S. stock market, from small companies to mega-caps.

Fund 2: International Total Market

This is VXUS or a similar fund. It gives you exposure to companies outside the U.S. Most experts suggest 20% to 40% of your stock allocation in international stocks.

That is it. Two funds. You rebalance once a year. You add money every month. You do not watch the market. You do not read financial news. You do not change your strategy when headlines scare you.

I have used this portfolio for years. It is boring. It is also the reason I have been able to stay invested through crashes and recoveries. Simple beats complicated almost every time.

If you are starting with very little, that is fine. You do not need much to start. You just need to start, and then let the compounding paths to your first $1M do the rest.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is VTI or VTSAX better?

VTI is slightly better for most people. It has a lower expense ratio (0.03% vs 0.04%), no minimum investment, and better tax efficiency in a taxable account. VTSAX is better only if you are at Vanguard, want automatic dollar-based investing, and prefer a mutual fund over an ETF.

Is FZROX as good as VTI?

Yes, for most people. FZROX has a 0.00% expense ratio, which is the lowest possible. It tracks a proprietary index instead of the standard CRSP index, but performance has been nearly identical. If you are at Fidelity, FZROX is an excellent choice. If you are not at Fidelity, VTI is more convenient.

What is the best index fund for beginners?

Any of these three funds is a great choice for beginners. VTI is the most flexible because you can buy it at almost any brokerage. FZROX is the cheapest if you are at Fidelity. VTSAX is the simplest for automatic investing if you are at Vanguard. Pick the one that fits your brokerage and start investing.

Conclusion

VTI, VTSAX, and FZROX are all excellent choices for wealth building. The differences between them are small. VTI is the most flexible. FZROX is the cheapest. VTSAX is the simplest for automatic investing at Vanguard. None of them will make or break your financial future.

What matters more is that you pick one, set up automatic contributions, and leave it alone for decades. The investors who win are not the ones who find the perfect fund. They are the ones who stay invested through good times and bad.

Run the numbers before you decide. Start building your plan today. Pick the fund that fits the brokerage you already have, automate it, and get back to the part of your life that actually matters.

Scroll to Top